Home About Us Bloomberg Initiative GOI Initiatives Parliament Q&A Contact Us
Latest News on Tobacco Tobacco Control Advocacy at Grassroots
Violations
Resources
Legislations On Tobacco Control
Success Stories
Photo Gallery
VHAI Journey on Tobacco   Control
Shame on you
Updates
Ask the experts
Resource Centre For Tobacco Free India

Voluntary Health Association of India
B-40, Qutab Institutional Area,
New Delhi - 110 016
Phone - 011-26518071-72,
  011-41688152-53
E-mail - info@rctfi.org
 
SMOKING BANNED IN PUBLIC PLACE: 2ND OCTOBER 2008

'Smoke-free from October 2' - Responses

Back  
Amitabh Thakur
SP, Intelligence
Faizabad

Dear Friends,

I agree with all our friends that these pictorial warnings to save lives campaigns are a welcome step in the direct direction. As we all know, spreading and disseminating message to every concerned person is a sin-qua-non for any project to become successful because such efforts can be have their true impact if they are performed in isolation and away from the public eyes.

If fact, these campaigns and these efforts are meant to let the people know about them and to sensitize them in full measure. Hence, whatever is being done in this direction is not only a boom to the cause it is also the right step which shall be having its impact sooner or later.

Amit Dwivedi
Citizen News Service
Lucknow
I completely agree with Ms Punam that the other countries have given significant examples of pictorial warnings.

The move comes after several rounds of deliberations since 2007, when Ramadoss had virtually admitted to being under pressure from the tobacco lobby not to implement pictorial warnings.

Definitely countries like Canada, Brazil which have set precedent that pictorial health warnings have been effective in reducing tobacco use, the prevalence has come down and people have started quitting A picture speaks a thousand words and is easily understood by the illiterate. It is one of the simple and effective ways to control tobacco with out spending any penny.
Warm wishes across,
 

Punam Singh
Nav Bharat Times
New Delhi, Delhi

Dear Friends,

Not only government but tobacco industry should also take responsibility for the healthy lives of people. Tobacco industry should not only be worry to make their profits more and more. This is utmost important that all products should have pictorial warning.

Several nations have implemented strong health warning label requirements. Examples include:

- Canada, whose health minister recently proposed enlarging the labels from 30% of the package face to 60%;
- Thailand, which has added the message "SMOKING CAUSES IMPOTENCE" to its list of required warnings.

India should also increase the space of pictorial warnings. Most smokers and non smokers want this information, and certainly want their children to have this information too.

Environmentally yours
 

Rahul Kumar
Citizen News Service
Lucknow

Dear Friends,

This is such a good efforts taken by `Group of Ministries' (GOM), for the specified pictorial warning on all tobacco products.

-This will help to reduce the number of tobacco users.
-It is evident that most of the tobacco products are being consumed in beedi farms by illiterate rural Indian.
-This warning will help them to quit this menace.
-Though, government has said that 40 per cent of the main surface area should be covered by this specific warning however, warning should be at least 60 per cent of the main surface area.
-Though, government has extended the date of the warning several time earlier, but, we hope that this time the date will not be extended.
-Tobacco industry should be strictly monitored by the government and civil society to follow this-rules.
 

Sarika Tripathi
Student- Public Health and Community Medicine
Department of Social Work
Lucknow University

Although Ministry of health & family welfare have given a time for the effective implementation of specified pictorial warnings, however, I don't think that ministry would be able to force tobacco industry to do this.
· Previous laws in this respect have failed due to lack of political commitment and delay in implementation of its various provisions. So, this time special concern should be given on this.
· This pictorial warning will raise awareness among general public about tobacco related diseases
· It will encourage people to quit tobacco consumption, but only to those who are willing to do so.
· Special focus should be on sensitizing youths on this issue.
· Special health educational programs should be conducted in rural and urban slums to raise awareness among people in those areas
 

Vinayak Prasad

Smoking ban cannot be compared to laws on wearing helmets

The demand for smoke free environment by nonsmokers will make smokers to self impose. This cannot be compared to violating laws such as wearing helmet as that does not harm safety of others

The self regulation has to come from smokers. This will be possible when non smokers demand their rights. After all non smokers constitute 2/3rd of the population.

The provisions of fine is a deterrant. It has to be imposed but many state govts will not have the resources to do provide dedicated manpower. The demand for smoke free environment by nonsmokers will make smokers to self impose. This cannot be compared to violating laws such as wearing helmet as that does not harm safety of others.

 

AFTC: October 2nd bodes well for all Indians
Dr Mira Aghi
Advocacy Forum for Tobacco Control (AFTC)

October 2nd bodes well for all Indians. It reaffirms that it is their health which matters and not the profits  from the sale of cigarettes.
 
Smoke-free policies have shown marked changes in the overall health of people wherever they have been implemented.We learn that policies that ban smoking in public places are effective in reducing passive smoking among non-smokers.  But in addition to that, they also protect vulnerable groups such as children and infants, adults with cardiac or respiratory disease, and pregnant women against the adverse effects of environmental tobacco smoke. Smoke-free policies in public places send a clear message to young people about non-smoking being the norm. They reduce the numbers of adults that young people see smoking.

In the workplace, smoke-free policies prompt some people to quit smoking right away. There is evidence that about 4% of the workforce gives up smoking on their own whereas many reduce the number of cigarettes they smoke as a matter of habit. It has also been observed that once the smoke-free policies are introduced, public support increases progressively. Strongly enforced smoke-free policies in schools have resulted in lowering prevalence of smoking among schoolchildren.

In fact we can say that smoke-free policies work as a strategy for reducing smoking in the population.
 

Well done Ramadoss  
Madhu Agrawal
Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh

Even though some steps of present Union Health Minister have been in controversy, yet he deserves full compliments for his efforts to push country towards a smoke-free country by successfully implementing "Workplace Smoke-Free Policy" from 2nd October. It is good that the Apex Court supported Ramadoss policy by dismissing petition of cigarette manufacturers seeking stay on government-policy discouraging use of tobacco.

It is to be seen how far the policy will be successful in practice. But only remedy to practically curb smoking is to follow sensible countries like Bhutan and Ireland by imposing a complete ban on manufacture and sale of cigarettes in the country. Even family-members of smokers will support such a bold step, because it is the family which suffers from death of persons caused by smoking.

Smoking is an addiction started out of fashion at the young age when initial puffs even cause discomfort. Revenue-loss from ban on cigarettes will be more than compensated by funds saved on tobacco-related diseases. If self-regulation is the policy to check human evils, then Union Government should withdraw attempt-to-suicide from Indian Penal Code. Likewise using helmets by scooterists should also be made self-regulatory rather than being forced as compulsory.
 

Jitendra Dwivedi
General Secretary
Abhinav Bharat Foundation
Lucknow

Dear all,

First of all let me congratulate to all public health advocates and concerned authorities that Supreme Court has also given its green signal to stop smoking at public places। So now we can reduce the number of second-hand tobacco hazards. Electronic air cleaners, air purification systems and "smokeless" ashtrays can double or triple the rate of clearing the air of smoke। Unfortunately, extensive studies have shown that there is no level of ventilation that will eliminate the harmful effects of second-hand smoke.

If you're a smoker, try to explain what the addiction is like। Be honest about your own worries and feelings of guilt. So let's stop smoking and tobacco use not only in our homes but in public places too, for a healthy, prosperous and smoke-free nation.
 

India embraces smoke-free policies on Gandhi Jayanti
To listen to this article as English audio podcast, click here
India has boldly enforced the smoke-free policies banning smoking in public places and private areas with public access from 2 October 2008 – the birth anniversary of the father of nation Mahatma Gandhi.

The government of India and countless people who have been advocating the enforcement of public health policies need due credit. It was certainly not so easy, more so because of the financially robust, strategically shrewd tobacco industry that has mastered the art of circumventing public interest policies and promoting a product (tobacco) that kills even when used as intended by the manufacturer.

The tobacco industry, and other corporations or associations like ITC ltd, Indian Hotel Association and others, filed more than 70 court cases against the ban on smoking in public places from October 2. But the honorable Supreme Court declined to delay the enforcement of these public interest policies and upheld public health over corporate profits.

India with more than a billion people had a large number of people who smoke cigarettes or beedis (tobacco rolled in `tendu' leaf). The benefit of smoke-free policies will certainly protect non-smokers from the dangerous exposure to tobacco smoke, which is called secondhand smoke.

Secondhand smoke, also know as environmental tobacco smoke (ETS), is a mixture of the smoke given off by the burning end of a cigarette, pipe or cigar and the smoke exhaled from the lungs of smokers. It is involuntarily inhaled by nonsmokers, lingers in the air hours after cigarettes have been extinguished and can cause or exacerbate a wide range of adverse health effects, including cancer, respiratory infections, and asthma. Secondhand smoke has been classified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as a known cause of cancer in humans (Group A carcinogen).

Secondhand smoke exposure causes disease and premature death in children and adults who do not smoke. Nonsmokers exposed to secondhand smoke at work are at increased risk for adverse health effects.

Not only non-smokers get the benefit of smoke-free policies, but also those who smoke are either smoking lesser cigarettes or they quit smoking, according to the studies. At least 4% of smokers are likely to quit smoking.

However enforcing the public health policies will largely bank on the meaningful participation of civil society – at every step. People need to be at the centre-stage if India is to realize enforcement of these policies. And this certainly will happen over a period of time, as awareness increases, perceptions change as people are informed and the benefits of enforcing public health policies in our own homes, offices and other places we spend our lives in, become pronounced.

October 2 is indeed a beginning for India. Let us hope that India is able to set a good precedent where civil society does join hands with governments to enforce public interest policies effectively.

 

R. ARUL
PASUMAI THAAYAGAM (Green Motherland)

Dear Friends

On Oct 2, PASUMAI THAAYAGAM (Green Motherland) launched a citywide Awareness campaign on Smoking Ban – His Excellency Governor of Tamil Nadu Shri. Surjit Singh Barnala inaugurated the campaign and Pasumai Thaayagam President Mrs. Sowmiya Anbumani presided over the function at Raj Bhavan, Chennai.

Five cultural groups participated in this programme. Cultural programmes, pamphlet distribution, door-to-door awareness campaign and other activities organized at more than 60 places all over Chennai.

Hon'ble Union Health Minister Dr. Anbumani Ramadoss participated in this Awareness campaign at Koyambedu CMBT Bus Stand, Chennai
With regards
 

Shobha Shukla, Loreto Convent

Dearest all, It is a basic human right to be able to breathe fresh and unpolluted air. So let us join hands to say NO to all sorts of air pollutants including CIGARETTE SMOKE, which is the deadliest of all. Let us help the government in imposing a complete ban on smoking in public places. Our nation's health and our environment' s well being is far more important than a smoker's momentary delight.

Although smoke-free ordinances exist in many cities across the country, more needs to be done to protect the health of all people, especially children. Continuing education in our schools and in the workplace can help shed light on this sensitive subject. Every individual is entitled to breathe clean, fresh air, free from the harmful effects of secondhand smoke. Please stop smoking in and out of public places. Live and let live a smokeless life.

Shobha Shukla
Senior Teacher-Loreto Convent
Lucknow
 

For bartenders, it's occupational hazard
Kounteya Sinha, The Times of India
Saturday, 13 September 2008


Excerpt:
A recent study conducted by Delhi's Vallabhbhai Patel Chest Institute (VPCI) to gauge the extent of harmful passive smoking among 50 non-smoking bartenders and waiters found ''significantly high levels'' of carbon monoxide (CO) in their body.

The average CO level in those who worked for around nine hours in smoke-filled discos and pubs was as high as 9.8 ppm (parts per million), while those who worked for more than 10 hours had CO level of 10.38 ppm. Some non-smoking bartenders had CO levels between 16-20 ppm — as found in chain smokers. In comparison, the average CO level in 50 nonsmokers who were not exposed to environmental tobacco smoke was 4.5 ppm.

Scientists say the normal CO level in nonsmokers is around 4 ppm.

''Nearly 24% of the bartenders had CO levels between 10-20 ppm, while 74% had CO levels between 6-10 ppm. Only 2% of this group had CO levels below 6 ppm. Around 4% of them had already developed respiratory problems like bronchitis,' ' Dr Raj Kumar, HoD of VPCI's department of respiratory allergy and applied immunology, told TOI.

CO robs a person's muscles, brain and body tissues of oxygen, making the whole body, especially the heart, work harder. It increases the amount of cholesterol and constricts blood vessels. Over time, it clogs up the heart arteries and causes a heart attack.

Reduced oxygen supply also weakens the bones, joints and muscles, increasing chances of fractures and tissue injuries. It also makes a lot less air enter the lungs.

Dr Kumar said the abnormally high CO levels in non-smoking bartenders exposed to passive smoking suggested they were prone to developing tobacco related diseases like cancer.

'We compared the CO levels of non-smoking bartenders who were exposed to environmental tobacco smoke and 50 others who were not. Subjects from both these sections underwent breath test with mini smoke analysers. CO levels were very high in those non-smokers who were exposed to passive smoking,'' Dr Kumar added.

Shockingly, 94% of the bartenders and waiters were not aware of the dangers of passive smoking. Nearly 48% of them worked nine-hour night shifts in bars and restaurants.

The average age of the bartenders was 39 years with a majority of them having worked for less than 10 years. During the survey, 84% of the bartenders and waiters said they felt stuffy.

Experts say SHS contains 4,000 different chemicals, 50 of which are carcinogenic and are known to cause danger. SHS has double the amount of nicotine and tar than the smoke inhaled by smokers. It also has five times the CO which decreases the amount of oxygen in blood.

Exposure to SHS for as little as 8-20 minutes can cause physical reactions linked to the heart. The heart rate increases, the heart's oxygen supply decreases and blood vessels constrict. This increases the blood pressure and makes the heart work harder.

According the recent Global Youth Tobacco survey, 36.4% of teenage students in India were exposed to SHS inside their homes and nearly 49% were exposed to it outside.

Non-smokers exposed to SHS have a 25% excess risk of coronary heart disease compared to non-smokers who are not exposed to smoke.

SHS exposure causes diseases and a premature death in children and adults who do not smoke. It causes lung cancer, heart disease, chronic lung ailments such as bronchitis and asthma, sudden infant death syndrome and low birth weight in pregnant women exposed to


No smoking in pubs
Megha Suri, The Times of India
Saturday, 13 September 2008


Excerpt:
Owners say they may have to ban smoking in pubs for the time being as creating a separate enclosure will require complete redesign. Be prepared to step into ''smoking prohibited'' pubs and discos on October 2. Even as the health ministry plans to come out with a public notice giving out the specifications for the smoking enclosures in pubs and restaurants by next week, pub owners in the city fear they will have to prohibit smoking on their premises till the required infrastructure is put in place.

''We are looking at creating a separate smoking enclosure and have even consulted our architects. But there is no clarity on the specifications set by the government for smoking zones yet. Since the entire ambience will get affected with the changes, I am hoping for an extension of the October 2 deadline. Otherwise, we will have to make the place entirely non-smoking till the designated smoking area is ready,'' said Rajiv Sarna of F-bar...

Added Kashif Farooq of Urban Pind: ''The changes being suggested are next to impossible to be carried out in a running set-up. The property will need to be completely redesigned. There are about 200 outlets running in the Capital which will need to incorporate smoking enclosures in their existing designs. For us, fortunately, there is a terrace which we are thinking of converting into a smoking zone.''

As confusion prevails over the specifications of the enclosures, a senior official from the health ministry told Times City that a public notice has been drafted which will be out next week. ''The public notice will be published and also be made available on the ministry's website next week. It will give details about the features which the smoking enclosures need to have. The space, essentially, has to have a good ventilation system and must be segregated from the rest of the restaurant. We are also advising self-service so that waiters and other restaurant staff are not exposed to the smoke,'' said the official.


Smoking Buddha making Kolkata lose international aid
Mumbai Mirror News, Mumbai, Maharashtra
Tuesday, 16 September 2008

Excerpt:

Shocking as it may sound, West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya' s smoking habits are making state capital Kolkata lose out on "millions of dollars" in international funds to fight the tobacco menace.

"I myself formulated two applications in the last six months on behalf of Kolkata to fund the city to curb tobacco consumption. But both were rejected by the Bloomberg Initiative, a global programme to reduce tobacco use in low and middle income countries, as the administrative head himself smokes in public," said a senior World Health Organisation (WHO) official.

In the last couple of years, the eastern metropolis has lost out to other Indian cities at least thrice. In WB, a tidy 70% percent of the male population consume tobacco, the highest in the country. "When the Chief Minister himself smokes, how will others believe that the state or its capital is serious or even interested in controlling tobacco?" said the official


Tobacco - Need for effective regulation
M Govinda Rao, Business Standard, New Delhi, Delhi
2 September 2008


Excerpt:
The most important thing is to ban all forms of tobacco consumption in public places.
By now, it is well established that tobacco is the single-most important contributor to non-communicable diseases in India. India has the second-largest number of tobacco consumers. Almost 10 per cent of the world's tobacco consumers numbering 120 million are Indians. Interestingly, unlike in the west, 85 per cent of this is non-cigarette consumption in the form of bidis, chewing tobacco and paan.

With acceleration in economic growth and in keeping with significant increase in disposable incomes, tobacco consumption in India has shown a sharp increase in recent years. Not surprisingly, cigarette manufacturers from industrialised countries are strategically shifting their markets to emerging economies like India. At the same time, there is a growing realisation in civil society, the media and the government of the need to control the spread of the tobacco epidemic by enforcing regulations and making people aware of the mortality consequences of tobacco consumption. At the same time, the tobacco economy involves millions of workers who are directly or indirectly involved in farming, manufacturing and trade. Finding alternative sources of employment and incomes for these people must be a part of the action plan in curtailing the consumption of tobacco.



Smokers, beware! Even your boss can book you
Prashant K Nanda, The Hindustan Times, New Delhi, Delhi
1 September 2008


Excerpt: Smokers beware! The government is empowering school principals, postmen, railway stationmasters, even your boss to book you if you're caught smoking in a public place after Oct 2 - the birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi

The health ministry has already sent the rule for gazette notification and will make it public in the second week of September.

"The government is yet to approve a fine of Rs.2,000 for those caught smoking in public," said a senior health ministry official. "So we are implementing the new Smoking in Public Places Rules 2008 with the old fine amount - up to Rs.200."


The new rule will also expand the definition of public places from government buildings to include all office buildings, hospitals, schools, colleges, railway stations, airports, bus stands, hotels and restaurants.



Prez joins BMC in fight against city's hookah parlours
The Times of India, Mumbai, Maharashtra
Friday, 29 August 2008


President Pratibha Patil will join the BMC's fight against hookah parlours in the city. The first citizen has promised that during her visit to Mumbai during a world conclave against tobacco on March 8, she will speak out against restaurants serving hookahs, which are popular among college and school-going youngsters.

Patil met mayor Shubha Raul in Delhi on Thursday and showed interest in the civic corporation' s drive against these parlours. The BMC has issued warning notices to many parlours, which had obtained licences under Section 394 of the BMC Act. Read more



Dear friends,

I am the Chairman, Crusade Against Tobacco -a branch of the Neil Charitable Trust.

From the year 2004 when the Act was implemented, I have been complaining to all the authorities both at the centre and the State i.e. Masharashtra about the non implementation of the Act. My letters were just being forwarded from one Government agency to another without any action being taken.

I have filed a PIL in the Bombay High Court where the second hearing is coming on 23rd October, 2008 about the non implementation of the Act.

In Bombay I have been complaining about the BMC smoking and it is sad to say that very senior officials in the BMC are smoking and nobody can take action against them.

In Delhi when I was there on 17th, 18th and 19th September, 2008, I caught 45 people smoking in the Nirman Bhawan itself and the people were fined.

I found that in most of the Government Offices that I had visited during those three days, smoking was going on.

I think Ramadoss will be successful if he will place smoke detectors in all cabins/toilets of public places.

Vincent Nazareth
Chairman
Crusade Against Tobacco

 
Back